After 6 months of testing (and 20+ years of experience), we’ve picked our top electric humidors from the 21 we tested out of 37 we considered. Our independent reviews are based solely on devices bought online, so no cherry-picked units here. The clear winner in our tests was the NewAir 250 Count humidor.
Our team reviewed each humidor based on temperature control, seal, materials used, additional features, design, and capacity. We seasoned every humidor to 70% RH and 70 degrees temperature prior to the test. We always test with cigars in the humidors. To ensure accuracy, we relied on SMARTRO SC42 Professional Digital Hygrometers to check built-in devices.
Enjoy our work with no ads. Our reviews are made possible by affiliate links, helping us out while costing you nothing extra.
BEST OVERALL
NewAir 250 Count Humidor
– Up to 250 cigars – Digital hygrometer – Secure lock – Soft LED lighting – Cedar Shelves
After buying and testing the NewAir 250 for a month, it’s our favorite pick. This champ has a lot of impressive features, including digital temp controls, which allow you to heat or cool your cigars to just the right temperature, regardless of your region’s climate.
We were particularly in love with the Spanish cedar shelves and drawer. These not only improved the flavor of our stogies, but also played a good role in maintaining the perfect humidity level. The digital hygrometer has a clear display that makes it easy to check the humidity quickly. Plus, the upgraded lock and key keep our cigars safe.
After buying and testing the NewAir 250 for a month, it’s our favorite pick. This champ has a lot of impressive features, including digital temp controls, which allow you to heat or cool your cigars to just the right temperature, regardless of your region’s climate.
We were particularly in love with the Spanish cedar shelves and drawer. These not only improved the flavor of our stogies, but also played a good role in maintaining the perfect humidity level. The digital hygrometer has a clear display that makes it easy to check the humidity quickly. Plus, the upgraded lock and key keep our cigars safe.
We must admit, though, the initial setup took some time, and we faced a slight learning curve when using the touchscreen temperature control panel. However, once we got the hang of it, managing our collection was easy. As a team, we really liked how this humidor can be used in different ways – it’s compact enough to function as either a built-in or freestanding unit.
In a nutshell: – Opti-Temp™ provides good temperature control – Spanish cedar shelves and drawer enhance flavor and humidity control – Digital hygrometer offers quick, accurate readings – New lock and key for added protection – Freestanding or built-in design accommodates various spaces
In conclusion, despite the initial setup challenges, our experience with the NewAir 250 Count has been overwhelmingly positive. This investment in our cigar collection has been well worth the expense, and we totally recommend it to fellow aficionados.
3 years ago I purchased the Redford Lite humidor from Elegant Bar. Despite its compact design, it can store up to 1,250 cigars. The electronic climate control system keeps moisture and temperature at an exact level, while the Spanish cedar lining enhances the aroma of the cigars. And I love the Black Oak matte finish.
The Redford Lite has four drawer-style shelves, two angled for display and two flat ones. A sliding tray at the bottom maximizes storage. A tinted glass door prevents light damage, and the de-mist feature prevents fogging.
3 years ago I purchased the Redford Lite humidor from Elegant Bar. Despite its compact design, it can store up to 1,250 cigars. The electronic climate control system keeps moisture and temperature at an exact level, while the Spanish cedar lining enhances the aroma of the cigars. And I love the Black Oak matte finish
The Redford Lite has four drawer-style shelves, two angled for display and two flat ones. A sliding tray at the bottom maximizes storage. A tinted glass door prevents light damage, and the de-mist feature prevents fogging. Temperature (41-71°F) and humidity (56-78% RH) are adjustable through the touchscreen panel. The built-in LED lighting displays my collection nicely.
However, it’s not perfect. The slimmer width can be limiting, and I might need to upgrade to the Raching C380A if my collection grows. Overall, the Redford Lite is a solid choice (though a bit tight on space) for keeping my sticks safe and fresh.
I’ve used the Clevelander Electric Cabinet since 2019. This humidor comes with a stainless steel exterior and a glass door, combining good looks with durability.
Inside, it can house up to 250 cigars, and the three removable sliding trays allow easy organization, fitting entire cigar boxes. The thermoelectric cooling system, adjustable between 51°F – 64°F, keeps things perfectly stable. Plus, the digital hygrometer that comes with it (battery-powered) displays temperature and humidity in both Celsius and Fahrenheit.
I’ve used the Clevelander Electric Cabinet since 2019. This humidor comes with a stainless steel exterior and a glass door, combining good looks with durability.
Inside, it can house up to 250 cigars, and the three removable sliding trays allow easy organization, fitting entire cigar boxes. The thermoelectric cooling system, adjustable between 51°F – 64°F, keeps things perfectly stable. Plus, the digital hygrometer that comes with it (battery-powered) displays temperature and humidity in both Celsius and Fahrenheit.
However, some drawbacks include not clear setup instructions and difficult battery replacement. To achieve good humidity, I suggest buying Boveda packs ahead of time and taking a few days to stabilize before storing cigars.
The water reservoir at the base keeps decent humidity levels. The electronic control panel is user-friendly, making it easy to manage temperature and lighting. While it’s not small, the humidor is easy to carry and overall great.
Milan and I recently had the opportunity to test the Schmecke 3-in-1 Humidor, and it did not disappoint. The unit maintains ideal conditions for up to 400 Churchill cigars. Here’s what caught our attention:
Effortless operation: The digital panel makes tweaking temperature and humidity easy.
Cool design: With stainless trim and a tinted glass door, it looks great in any space.
Milan and I recently had the opportunity to test the Schmecke 3-in-1 Humidor, and it did not disappoint. The unit maintains ideal conditions for up to 400 Churchill cigars. Here’s what caught our attention:
Effortless operation: The digital panel makes tweaking temperature and humidity easy.
Cool design: With stainless trim and a tinted glass door, it looks great in any space.
Spanish cedar interior: Premium shelves and drawers not only keep flavor, but also keep the cigar beetles away.
Nonetheless, one drawback: weighing 48.5 lbs, it was difficult for us to move the unit around.
Even though it’s quite heavy, the Schmécké cooler’s quiet, zero-vibration compressor keeps things calm, making it good for both indoor and outdoor use. This guy has great features, plenty of space, and looks fantastic – perfect for cigar fans.
This one was gifted to us by a friend. Designed with the cigar aficionado in mind, this humidor comes with top-notch features:
– Heating and cooling capabilities (54℉ to 74℉); – Unpainted Spanish cedar wood for that authentic aroma and enhanced taste; – 360-degree circulating air system for uniform temperature and humidity.
This one was gifted to us by a friend. Designed with the cigar aficionado in mind, this humidor comes with top-notch features:
– Heating and cooling capabilities (54℉ to 74℉); – Unpainted Spanish cedar wood for that authentic aroma and enhanced taste; – 360-degree circulating air system for uniform temperature and humidity.
The craftsmanship of this beauty is truly great. Its double-layer hollow tempered glass door effectively deals with external heat and humidity changes, while the digital touchscreen control panel makes it super easy to use. And its low noise (≤38 dB) makes it suitable for any environment.
We were able to store 130 cigars (loose) in the humidor, thanks to the 2 adjustable shelves and 1 drawer. However, we did find that the higrometer on the cedar drawer may not be as accurate as we’d like.
In conclusion, the humidor is an excellent storage solution, despite some minor issues.
We recently found this model Whynter. This nice, freestanding humidor has a 250+ cigar capacity, enough space for the average collection.
It maintains good humidity (62%-75%) and has an analog hygrometer and humidity tray. We love the thermoelectric cooling system – it’s energy-efficient, keeps pests out, and prevents cigars from drying out better than compressor units. With Spanish cedar shelves and a roomy drawer, it gives off a pleasant, subtle aroma.
We recently found this model Whynter. This nice, freestanding humidor has a 250+ cigar capacity, enough space for the average collection.
It maintains good humidity (62%-75%) and has an analog hygrometer and humidity tray. We love the thermoelectric cooling system – it’s energy-efficient, keeps pests out, and prevents cigars from drying out better than compressor units. With Spanish cedar shelves and a roomy drawer, it gives off a pleasant, subtle aroma.
Features we like: – 1.2 cu. ft capacity – Vibration-free cooling – LCD temperature display – Adjustable thermostat (52ºF-65ºF)
One minor drawback: the hygrometer’s analog design might not be great for people who prefer digital ones.
Ventilation: Auxiliary fan for moisture distribution;
Humidifier: Yes;
Temperature control: Cooling and heating options available;
Materials: Solid wood (cherry finish), Spanish cedar trays & shelves;
Hygrometer: Digital;
Key Features: 12 drawer style shelves on metal slides. Removable cedar trays with dividers. White LED lighting. 1-year parts & labor warranty. Lock and key set.
Around a year ago, our team had the pleasure of using the Reagan cabinet humidor, a luxurious piece that we really like. Adelina’s father, a fellow friend of the leaf, owns this remarkable cabinet, and we were in love with its features.
Outstanding Storage Capacity: This bad boy can hold a staggering 4,000 cigars, making it perfect for the big collectors. Twelve drawer-style shelves, equipped with metal slides and adjustable dividers, make organization really simple.
Dual-Zone Climate Control: The Reagan humidor features individual temperature and humidity controls for each side, allowing for exact control of the cabinet’s conditions. The built-in humidifier and heating/cooling systems ensure cigars are maintained in good condition.
Around a year ago, our team had the pleasure of using the Reagan cabinet humidor, a luxurious piece that we really like. Adelina’s father, a fellow friend of the leaf, owns this remarkable cabinet, and we were in love with its features.
Outstanding Storage Capacity: This bad boy can hold a staggering 4,000 cigars, making it perfect for the big collectors. Twelve drawer-style shelves, equipped with metal slides and adjustable dividers, make organization really simple.
Dual-Zone Climate Control: The Reagan humidor features individual temperature and humidity controls for each side, allowing for exact control of the cabinet’s conditions. The built-in humidifier and heating/cooling systems ensure cigars are maintained in good conditions.
Elegant Design: The deep cherry wood finish, detailed wood side panels, and decorative brass handles add a touch of sophistication to any space.
LED Lighting: White LED lights light up the interior, making it easy to see.
However, it’s important to mention a few drawbacks highlighted by users: 1. Some reported that the humidity readings were not calibrated correctly upon arrival, which required some adjustments. 2. A few users believe it might not be the absolute best cabinet out there but agree that it meets or exceeds expectations. 3. The humidification system might not meet all expectations.
Despite these small problems, the Reagan Electronic Cigar Humidor is still a great option for serious cigar collectors, thanks to its attractive design and large storage capacity.
Milan from our review team has owned this humidor since 2021, so we’ve seen its impressive features in action. With a built-in humidification system, this humidor effortlessly takes care of moisture levels – a game changer. Having an XL capacity, it can hold up to 840 cigars, making sure you’ll likely never run out of space for your cigar collection.
But there’s more! The Opti-Temp feature offers precise temperature control allowing you to maintain decent conditions for your stogies. The Spanish cedar drawers, paired with LED spotlights, provide a great feeling. Despite its many strengths, one drawback we found is the humidor’s weight – at 81.4 pounds, it’s not the easiest to move around.
Milan from our review team has owned this humidor since 2021, so we’ve seen its impressive features in action. With a built-in humidification system, this humidor effortlessly takes care of moisture levels – a game changer. Having an XL capacity, it can hold up to 840 cigars, making sure you’ll likely never run out of space for your cigar collection.
But there’s more! The Opti-Temp feature offers precise temperature control allowing you to maintain decent conditions for your stogies. The Spanish cedar drawers, paired with LED spotlights, provide a great feeling. Despite its many strengths, one drawback we found is the humidor’s weight – at 81.4 pounds, it’s not the easiest to move around.
In summary, the NewAir 840 Count Cigar Humidor is a good choice. It offers excellent climate control, space, and a modern design, even though it’s a bit heavy. Our team absolutely recommends giving this humidor a try.
My grandfather owns this awesome boy. Made from imported Spanish cedarwood, this beautiful humidor can hold an impressive 800-900 cigars, making it perfect for both enthusiasts and collectors.
The C230A is just great for keeping cigars fresh, creating a mini-climate system inside. The design includes a single-core refrigeration system that removes frost and condensation and keeps humidity levels within ±3% -perfect for storing cigars in any kind of weather!
I was amazed by how cool this system keeps the air, with fans on the top and bottom and air vents on each shelf. It has sensors that check the temperature and humidity to make sure the cigars are always in peak condition.
My grandfather owns this awesome boy. Made from imported Spanish cedarwood, this beautiful humidor can hold an impressive 800-900 cigars, making it perfect for both enthusiasts and collectors.
The C230A is just great for keeping cigars fresh, creating a mini-climate system inside. The design includes a single-core refrigeration system that removes frost and condensation and keeps humidity levels within ±3% -perfect for storing cigars in any kind of weather!
I was amazed by how cool this system keeps the air, with fans on the top and bottom and air vents on each shelf. It has sensors that check the temperature and humidity to make sure the cigars are always in peak condition.
Cedar (which absorbs moisture well) helps regulate humidity inside the C230A, showing how well it’s designed to prevent fogging.
However, it’s important to note that the C230A is pretty heavy, weighing 185 lbs, which makes it hard to move. Also, it only comes in two colors, black or brown, which might not suit everyone’s taste.
The best feature, though, is the rimless tempered double-glass door with a lock, which includes an LCD touchscreen. This cool screen shows the temperature and humidity, so you don’t have to keep opening the door to check.
Key Features: Noise level of <45 dBa. Eco-friendly R600a refrigerant. Security lock and key. Spanish cedar drawers and shelves. Soft interior LED lighting.
We recently got our hands on the Whynter 4.2 cu.ft. cabinet cooler. Perfect for both cigar pros and casual smokers, this humidor keeps your cigars tasting great and safe from damage.
First off, the humidor has a nice and sophisticated design. Its adjustable digital hygrometer (65% – 75%) and thermostat (64ºF – 72ºF) provide optimal storage conditions. Here’s what we found impressive:
– 4.2 cu. ft. capacity, holding up to 650+ cigars; – Freestanding setup; – Eco-friendly compressor cooling system; – Spanish cedar drawers and shelves; – Activated carbon filters to eliminate odors.
We recently got our hands on the Whynter 4.2 cu.ft. cabinet cooler. Perfect for both cigar pros and casual smokers, this humidor keeps your cigars tasting great and safe from damage.
First off, the humidor has a nice and sophisticated design. Its adjustable digital hygrometer (65% – 75%) and thermostat (64ºF – 72ºF) provide optimal storage conditions. Here’s what we found impressive:
– 4.2 cu. ft. capacity, holding up to 650+ cigars; – Freestanding setup; – Eco-friendly compressor cooling system; – Spanish cedar drawers and shelves; – Activated carbon filters to eliminate odors.
But we did identify two drawbacks. The humidor’s storage for boxes is limited, making it difficult for collectors who prefer keeping cigars in their original packaging. Additionally, some users reported inconsistencies in the built-in thermostat and hygrometer readings.
In our experience, the Whynter humidor delivered on its promise of maintaining temperature and humidity levels,. It has dual fan-forced circulation ensuring even distribution. The Spanish cedar drawers not only helped maintain humidity but also gave off a pleasant aroma that complemented the cigars. We also liked the security lock and key.
Here is how we rated the electric humidors listed on the page:
Temperature Control
Temperature regulation was a top priority in our tests, since it directly affects cigar quality. We assessed each unit’s ability to maintain a consistent temperature, even when external conditions fluctuated. By closely monitoring the temperature settings and actual temperature, we caught any differences and confirmed the humidor’s performance.
Seal
You can’t beat an airtight seal – it’s absolutely essential. Without a good seal humidity can fluctuate, damaging your cigars. We carefully checked each humidor’s seal to make sure humidity stayed perfect and moisture didn’t escape.
Materials Used
The materials used in a humidor affect how long it’ll last and how well it keeps humidity. We checked out each electric humidor from top to bottom (casing, shelves, and all) and gave good ratings to those that did the best job holding humidity and were well-built.
Design
Aesthetic appeal might not be the primary concern for every cigar enthusiast, but a well-designed humidor can enhance your collection and its surroundings. We considered the visual impact and practicality of each humidor’s design, taking into account elements such as display windows, lighting, and accessibility.
Capacity
Different cigar collectors have varying capacity requirements. We evaluated humidors across a range of sizes, ensuring there’s something for everyone, from the casual aficionado to the serious connoisseur.
Why Buy a Thermoelectric Humidor?
An electric humidor offers several advantages over traditional humidors. Firstly, it provides better temperature and humidity control, allowing for precise adjustments and ensuring ideal storage conditions. This feature is especially beneficial for those living in regions with extreme temperature fluctuations, as it helps maintain consistency for your cigars.
Secondly, electric humidors can accommodate larger collections, often featuring multiple shelves and compartments. This organization allows you to store and showcase your cigars more effectively, and in some cases, even age them.
Lastly, an electric humidor often comes with advanced features, such as digital hygrometers and thermoelectric cooling systems. These can offer convenience, improved functionality, and an overall better experience.
In summary, investing in an electric cigar humidor can provide better protection for your collection, while adding a touch of sophistication and convenience to your cigar storage.
Disclaimer: www.smoking-hub.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com
FAQ
Are electric humidors worth it?
Yes, electric humidors are worth it, as they provide precise temperature and humidity control, accommodate larger collections, and often include advanced features for a superior cigar storage experience.
How long do cigars last in an electric humidor?
Cigars can last for several years in an electric humidor when properly maintained, with some aficionados successfully aging their cigars for a decade or more.
How often should I check the humidity and temperature levels inside my electric humidor?
It’s best to check the humidity and temperature levels inside your electric humidor at least once a week to ensure optimal conditions for your cigars.
What are some common signs that my electric humidor might not be functioning properly?
Common signs include fluctuating temperature and humidity levels, difficulty maintaining desired settings, visible mold or mildew, and cigars developing a musty smell or becoming too dry.
If you found it useful, share with your fellow aficionados:
Oliver Jones PhD
Jones, Oliver Jones, content creator and editor. My passion for smoking has deep roots: my grandfather was a tobacco curer, and my first job was as a tobacconist. Ever since my grandfather introduced me to Cuban cigars in the 90s, I've been captivated by the relaxed enjoyment and rich culture surrounding them. My favorite cigar? It's always the next premium blend I try, and the same goes for pipes. So here I am, sharing my lifetime of knowledge and experience to help you discover your next favorite cigar or pipe.
You can reach out to me for questions anytime via oliverjones@smoking-hub.com.
One comment
I own two built in 26 inch by 36 inch wide by 8 foot tall built in humidors.
I had a vigilante Humidor ( Electric and autofill with running water) in lasted 14 years they do not make the unit I had anymore and not repairable
Any experience with an electric fan dispersed, autofill humidification system for a built in humidor
I own two built in 26 inch by 36 inch wide by 8 foot tall built in humidors.
I had a vigilante Humidor ( Electric and autofill with running water) in lasted 14 years they do not make the unit I had anymore and not repairable
Any experience with an electric fan dispersed, autofill humidification system for a built in humidor